# An introduction of the topic Please cite sources appropriately: References are n

An introduction of the topic

Please cite sources appropriately: References are not linked or expressed correctly. Please consider having the references as this Wiki template, https://optimization.cbe.cornell.edu/index.php?title＝Quantum_computing_for_optimization

Introduction is very short for a well-recognized topic. Please expand significantly. You may refer to the Wiki examples to get an idea on writing the Introduction to a topic.

An illustration might be useful here.

Theory, methodology, and/or algorithmic discussions

The algorithm described here considers only binary integer variables. However, MINLP problems may include non-binary integer variables too. Please update the method or provide a short desсrіption of the assumptions that the MINLP problem needs to satisfy in order for the presented technique to be applicable.

Use linked citations please as the Wiki template above.

Please provide steps in a more organized way. Please consider proper formatting of the algorithm as pseudocode. Algorithms also must be accompanied with high level summary and discussion on its most important high level ideas.

Step 2 is missing yet it is referenced in the text multiple times. Please address this in addition to the above comment.

An illustration might be useful here as well.

Please explain what a Gomory Cut is. If the topic is available on optimization.cb.cornell.edu, you can link it.

The current equations seem to be simple text written in Italics. All mathematical symbols and equations should be formatted via LaTex.

Please format the math programs with equations and notations using formulations in lecture notes as templates.

At least one numerical example

Please add a few sentences to show the transition from problem to solution.

Please show a step-by-step solution in the example. The solution is incomplete. The Numerical Example section needs a ″step-by-step″ calculation process and a clear presentation of each step′s results. (again, similar to the way of solving an HW problem).

Please use the equation editor for equations or mathematical symbols. – All mathematical symbols and equations should be formatted via LaTex – this is a learning objective of the Wiki assignment. You can find some useful links on converting your equations/symbols into LaTex code here: (https://optimization.cbe.cornell.edu/index.php?title＝Help:Contents). Again, any formatting issue will incur a ″compound″ penalty in the grading.

This example does not follow the MINLP structure discussed in the above section since binary variables are missing. Branch and bound may not be appropriate for such problems. Please provide an appropriate numerical example and solve it according to the above comments.

Make sure your example is not taken from a book as that is strictly disallowed.

A section to discuss and/or illustrate the applications

This section is not well-formatted. Please provide 3 applications and explain each in a few sentences and how BB for MINLP could be used. Also, please eliminate having multiple sections (Application, Mathematical problem, industrial application). All these could be merged together.

This section should be at least a paragraph to discuss relevant applications. Each application should be explicitly linked to the page topic. A few keywords do not meet the requirement at all.

A conclusion section:

The sentence is hard to understand ″a scheme that grows exponentially because″ please use a simple language. Is it also theoretically correct? It is also not mentioned and explained earlier. Thus, please avoid introducing new concepts or terms at the end.

Please use summarizing sentences to describe earlier sections instead of introducing new concepts/discussion.

References

Too few references overall, you should aggregate information from multiple sources. A quick Google scholar search could provide relevant references.

References are not expressed correctly. Please consider having the references as this Wiki template, https://optimization.cbe.cornell.edu/index.php?title＝Quantum_computing_for_optimization

Please follow the standard reference style – the current format is incorrect.